The Business Post: Donald MacDonald on the challenges facing Ireland’s private rental market

Posted on

“Investors will tend to buy into stabilised portfolios as they’re brought to the market over the next 24 months,” Donald MacDonald, director, Hooke & MacDonald

In the week that US investment manager Barings agreed to acquire Ires Reit for about €731 million, it is clear that investors remain interested in Ireland’s private rental market.

Nonetheless, high costs, weak project viability and delivery barriers are holding back new supply.

The sector is at a crossroads: investors are interested, but it is easier to put money into completed, income-producing properties than into new construction.

That was the message from Donald MacDonald of Hooke & MacDonald, who described interest from both domestic and international investors who are “here to fund Irish residential, private rental sector investments or multifamily investments.

“But those investors will tend to buy into stabilised portfolios as they’re brought to the market over the next 24 months. There are very limited opportunities to get involved in new projects, however, because their viability is challenged.”

The logic is clear: buying an existing building gives investors an asset with an established income stream. Building a new one means taking on construction costs, delivery risks and the challenge of achieving an acceptable return.

Recent rental reforms have helped make the investment environment more predictable, McDonald said, providing clarity on rent increases when tenants leave while also strengthening tenant protections.

But a more predictable policy framework cannot, on its own, make new apartment development stack up.

High construction costs and the rents achievable mean it is difficult to deliver an acceptable return.

“In most parts of the country, it’s very hard to make that work,” MacDonald said. Outside Dublin, it is “probably impossible,” while in Dublin it is “very difficult,” he said.

The result is a market where investors may be willing to buy, but developers have little incentive to build.

Stabilised assets can change hands, giving long-time owners liquidity and new investors access to the market. But those transactions do not add homes.

The gap between delivery and need is stark. MacDonald cited KPMG and Property Industry Ireland estimates that annual private rental apartment delivery would need to reach about 8,000 units in 2026 and rise to 12,000 by 2030. Current delivery, he said, is “in the hundreds rather than the thousands.”

So while a small number of schemes are progressing, it is nothing close to the scale required.

Among the schemes on site are the Glass Bottle development in Dublin 4, where there are about 1,510 apartments built and up to 3,800 planned.

Similarly, the Carriageworks in Dublin’s North Wall incorporates just over 700 apartments; while Marshall Yards, also in Dublin’s Docklands, has about 554 build-to-rent apartments.

Meanwhile Marlet’s new mixed residential and commercial scheme, Claremont, comprises some 512 rental apartments on the Howth Road in North Dublin.

MacDonald also pointed to Lioncor’s Marmalade Lane in Dundrum, Dublin 16, which is set to deliver 463 apartments and eight three-storey, four-bedroom semi-detached houses.

Again, as well as this week’s Barings-Ires deal, another example of a large stabilised asset that transacted this year was Valpre Capital’s sale of the 134-apartment development at 18 Newmarket Square in Dublin 8 to MEAG, German reinsurance firm Munich RE’s asset manager in February.

Those examples highlight activity, but not a sufficient pipeline. MacDonald reiterated that while investors are reviewing development opportunities, a review does not mean a project can be built at a viable return.

What can help get schemes over the line are public supports and sales to different types of buyers.

MacDonald described a mixed-tenure development where some homes could be built for sale to first time buyers with support from Croí Cónaithe, some rented through the government’s Secure Tenancy Affordable Rental, or cost-rental ‘Star’ scheme, and others sold to the Land Development Agency, an Approved Housing Body or a local authority.

Without these different routes, he warned, “those apartment developments just won’t start.”

Yet those supports have limits. The Star scheme offers funding in return for long-term leases and discounted rents. MacDonald said the Land Development Agency had used Star funding for thousands of apartments, while private developers and operators had not used the scheme’s funding facility.

“The proof is in the fact that nobody in the private sector has got Star to work,” he said, while cautioning that he did not want to claim the scheme could never work.

On some sites, selling houses to owner-occupiers may be viable, while apartments need a public-sector or institutional buyer to make the overall project work. If that route is removed without a viable replacement, developers may decide not to proceed.

The immediate outlook is therefore two-speed: continuing investor interest in stabilised assets, but a weaker pipeline of new construction.

Investors can provide liquidity for owners looking to sell, but they are unlikely to build at scale unless the numbers justify the risk.

Ireland may have the capital and investor interest; the challenge is turning both into viable new homes.

Secret Link